A year on the Vision Bus Aotearoa: and the next stop is…

A year on the Vision Bus Aotearoa: and the next stop is…

The Vision Bus Aotearoa (VBA) is an initiative of the School of Optometry and Vision Science that provides comprehensive mobile eye care services to underserved schools, primarily in the South Auckland region. Recently we said farewell (but hopefully not goodbye) to our two most recent VBA staff—Sachi Rathod and Germaine Joblin—as they move on to new adventures.

The Vision Bus Aotearoa is funded by Peter and Rae Fehl, with support from Helen and Barbara Blake, Essilor, and the Buchanan Charitable Foundation.

It’s an early start for our Vision Bus Aotearoa staff. They’ve negotiated their way through peak hour traffic towards South Auckland in a 5-metre-long vehicle carrying expensive medical equipment. Everything on board has been painstakingly secured and double checked, because anything that can roll around, will.

After they’re let in to the school by the caretaker and navigated the inconveniently sized carpark, next comes the task of unpacking, setting up, and triple checking that the bus isn’t going to roll away unexpectedly.

It’s definitely not something I love doing on a Monday morning,” says Sachi Rathod wryly. Together with Germaine Joblin, the two have been the driving force (both figuratively and literally) behind the Vision Bus activities this past year.

But Sachi clearly loves it. As a recent graduate with a developing interest in rural healthcare and paediatric optometry, working on the Vision Bus was a perfect progression along her evolving career path, and one that has given her the autonomy and flexibility that many young optometrists can only dream of. She isn’t restricted by her job title, and describes her role as optometrist, teacher, administrator, support person, and of course, bus driver.

“It’s lots of fun,” says Sachi, “You can’t just arrive on site and start work like you would in a regular optometry clinic,” she explains. “Every day presents a completely different challenge and a completely different lot of kids.”

A need for children’s eye care in Aotearoa

But it’s the challenges that the kids face that have kept the wheels on the Vision Bus rolling this past couple of years. The underlying objective is to improve learning opportunities for Kiwi children, and that starts with addressing eye health in those who may not otherwise have access to eye care.

The cause of this problem is (largely) the significant cost of eye care services in this country. While New Zealand has some public funding for children’s eye care (via the Enable subsidy), this is not accessible to everyone who needs it, and many children go to school without corrected vision. These children face additional challenges, which can follow them into their adult lives.

Germaine Joblin is the other half of the Vision Bus’s 2024 optometry staff, and she describes the most rewarding part of this role as giving children the opportunity to read, participate in class, and hopefully go on to achieve their potential.

“Being able to see the smiles on their faces when they get their glasses, oh, that’s great,” she says.

Germaine is a long-term supporter of mobile eye care services, a passion that began when completing an advocacy project for the World Council of Optometry centred around a vision bus concept. For her, the opportunity to work on The School of Optometry and Vision Science’s VBA felt more like a calling.

“I had heard about it, but I didn’t realize it was actually created and on the road. So it was just a perfect pairing,” she recalls.

Germaine spends the rest of her time in private practice optometry and caring for her child (the latter being the harder role, she laughs), but it was her prior experiences as a volunteer optometrist in Africa, Mongolia, Nepal, and the Pacific Islands that have given her an appreciation for the unmet need for eye care that exists throughout the world. Her comparison with the situation in New Zealand is striking.

“What I’ve discovered on the Vision Bus, is the need—there’s a greater need here. I’ve done a lot of volunteer work overseas but to be honest, I think a lot of that volunteer work needs to be here,” she says.

What shocked her the most is the large number of young children presenting on the Vision Bus with keratoconus—a progressive thinning of the tissue at the front of the eye—which is more typically diagnosed during the teenage years and can lead to permanent vision loss if left untreated. While New Zealand currently has no population-based data describing how many children are affected, the condition is more common in Māori children, which may lead to the growing body of evidence describing inequities in eye health. Fortunately, the treatment options are both effective and publicly funded in New Zealand, if detected early.

Bringing uncorrected refractive error into focus

Aside from the disproportionately high rates of keratoconus, the most common diagnosis given on the VBA is refractive error—a condition where the image does not focus clearly on the retina at the back of the eye, making it difficult to see clearly. Often children and their parents may not realise there is a problem.

“It’s hard to detect because a lot of children can just get away with it and not realise that they can’t see things clearly all the time,” explains Sachi. “If everything’s a little bit fuzzy at all distances and you’ve just grown-up thinking that, you’re never really going to complain.”

Germaine explains how uncorrected refractive error in children can lead to permanent vision loss because the visual system hasn’t been stimulated at any early enough age. Importantly, a type of refractive error that’s particularly common on the Vision Bus is astigmatism, which when combined with other comorbidities that encourage eye rubbing (such as eczema and allergies) can push a child towards developing keratoconus.

Regular, comprehensive eye examinations by an optometrist are important to help identify and treat these problems early in a child’s life.

Germaine believes that New Zealand needs more vision buses out in schools and communities delivering eye examinations to children who are unlikely to have access to eyecare, and who may have vision problems that are not detected by New Zealand’s national B4 School Check vision screening programme.

“The problem with the B4 school screening is it doesn’t check for refractive error or the need for glasses,” says Germaine. “That’s a big problem. The other problem is it doesn’t check for keratoconus, and that’s huge.”

Helping children to wear their glasses

While the rates of refractive error are high, fortunately this condition can usually be corrected effectively with glasses, and reducing the rates of uncorrected refractive error remains the key focus of the Vision Bus.

Children who need glasses are given their first pair free of charge via the Community Spectacle Scheme and parents are advised how to access the Enable subsidy for their child’s eye care in future. The bus is equipped with a spectacle dispensary and employs a qualified dispensing optician (Emily Benefer) so that the children with refractive error can receive the treatment that they need on site, without having to seek care elsewhere. Germaine describes the selection of glasses “pretty groovy”.

However, building trust with children, whānau, and communities is the key factor in enabling children to wear their glasses. Unlike private practice optometry where glasses can be sold for high prices, the Vision Bus has an advantage as a neutral platform unaffiliated with commercial optometry, and Germaine recalls disbelief from many parents that the service is fully subsidised.

“People aren’t going to come and see us and get their eyes tested and think they’re going to be sold something,” says Germaine, “So that is powerful.”

When Germaine encounters reluctance from parents for their child to wear glasses, she tries to build trust by relating as a parent herself.

“It was taking a different approach to the way we communicated. Just coming across as a mother, not just as an optometrist, to hopefully get the importance across of not only having the eyes checked but to wear glasses.”

Community Coordinator Telusila Vea often plays a key role in communicating with families, drawing on her knowledge of public health and her experiences working with Pacific communities.

Sachi emphasises that the simple stressors of life, particularly in large family groups, make it more difficult for children to wear their glasses. She believes that optometrists should play a role in enabling children to wear their glasses.

“You cannot blame children for the system that they are born into and brought up in,” says Sachi. “They haven’t had a say in it. You have to talk to every single adult that exists around the child.”

Not one to stand idly by, Sachi describes some of the initiatives she and the other Vision Bus Aotearoa staff have put in place over the last year to improve communication so that children are better supported to wear their glasses. The staff accompany children back to class to explain the situation to the teacher, encourage the glasses to remain on school property to prevent them becoming lost in transit—particularly for children who live across multiple homes, and make extra efforts to contact parents who cannot be reached by phone.

“We send a giant Excel spreadsheet to every school at the end of our visit. We’re saying ‘Here are all the kids, here’s who needs glasses full time, here’s who needs glasses part-time, here’s who’s being referred to hospital.’ And that information gets passed down to school leaders, teachers, nurses, and also learning support people. So really, it’s just communicating to everyone through every means possible,” says Sachi.

And it appears to be working.

“We go back on follow-up day and so many more kids [are wearing glasses], their parents are more engaged, their teachers know that they should be wearing glasses,” she says.

This last year we’ve really put in place a lot of good procedures and policies to make sure that in the future [the Vision Bus Aotearoa] keeps going in a much more effective way.

Sachi Rathod

Professional Teaching Fellow on the VBA 2024

Driving forward the next generation of optometrists

Measuring the effectiveness of the Vision Bus goes deeper than counting children or spectacles or referrals. To make eye care more accessible to all children (and adults) will require a future workforce that is well-versed in equity and willing to take responsibility for changing the status quo.

The VBA is a step in this direction. As a teaching platform, the service allows Bachelor of Optometry students the opportunity to work with children from a range of different socioeconomic backgrounds, learning to navigate the challenges this presents with resilience and creativity. While the efficiency of a service delivered by trainee optometry students may be reduced compared to a conventional clinic, this is outweighed by the long-term benefits to the future optometry profession.

“It’s exposing these optometry students to real world inequities,” says Germaine, “They’re seeing not just children without glasses, they’re seeing children without lunches. Quite a real-world learning experience, which I think is awesome. The students need a bit more of that than what’s currently available.”

Germaine wonders whether more opportunities for current and future optometrists to experience the unmet need for eye care in New Zealand that exists outside of private practice would build up the optometry profession and ignite a passion for improving eye health.

“I do wonder if they’re exposed to this need, and again this sense of purpose and helping. I think that perhaps we’d get a greater love for optometry.”

But as she points out, changing the optometry workforce starts decades earlier, in the children who will grow up to become the eye care providers of the future. By delivering vision services to young children living in underserved communities, the Vision Bus is opening their eyes to optometry and seeding this profession in their minds as a future career option.  

“These kids have been exposed to optometry, and I think that’s wonderful too because we’re going to see more Māori and Pacific optometrists and that will bode well for the future,” she says.

On a personal level, Germaine clearly feels a deep sense of purpose and satisfaction in her work that shines through her eyes.

“I’ve been practicing for almost 24 years, and I love what I do still, and I think that’s because I have a great sense of purpose when I work. And I think possibly, that’s from my years of advocacy. You really get more of a sense of purpose like you’ve done something good. It’s a feel-good experience.”

The next stop is…

As 2024 drew to a close, Sachi and Germaine parked the bus back in the driveway and are now moving on to new adventures.

Inspired by her experiences in a research environment, Sachi aspires towards a PhD in public health and policy.

“I don’t want to let it go. It’s been such a cool job, it’s fantastic,” she says, “[But] I think after a year of changing processes on the bus, I think I’m just the kind of person who can’t stand it when things are not efficient. So, I really want to see what a better vision screening—better nationwide government-funded program—would look like for children.”

Meanwhile, Germaine seeks new opportunities to apply her advocacy skills, and she begins by advocating for the Vision Bus to continue along the road towards better eye health in Aotearoa.   

“I think one, it needs to continue and two, it needs to expand,” she says. “That’s perhaps the one frustration I had. I felt like we were only just helping a very small portion of children. I think we need to grow it. We need to have more buses.”

“I’ve just been so lucky to be in the forefront of this whole bus experience and advocating for children,” she says.

The Vision Bus Aotearoa is not just a mobile eye clinic—it’s an embodiment of optometry’s role in advocacy, education, and service. Everywhere it goes, whether it’s open days or media appearances, it captures attention and raises awareness.

Germaine Joblin

Professional Teaching Fellow on the VBA 2024

We welcome back Veeran Morar who returns as Professional Teaching Fellow on the VBA from 2025.

Sachi Rathod

Sachi Rathod

Optometrist and Professional Teaching Fellow

Germaine Joblin

Germaine Joblin

Optometrist and Professional Teaching Fellow

Joanna Black

Joanna Black

Deputy Head of School

Veeran Morar

Veeran Morar

Professional Teaching Fellow

Emily Benefer

Emily Benefer

Dispensing Optician & Professional Teaching Fellow

Telusila Vea

Telusila Vea

Community Coordinator

Four Community Eye Health students complete the first phase of their doctoral studies

Four Community Eye Health students complete the first phase of their doctoral studies

As 2024 draws to a close, we’d like to congratulate the four Community Eye Health PhD students who have successfully confirmed their candidature and moved into the next phase of their doctoral studies. During an intensive oral examination, our students demonstrated their developing skills as researchers by fielding questions from other academics, meeting the first official milestone in their doctoral degree.  Their confidence reflects the growing capacity of our Community Eye Health research team as we head into the second quarter of the century.

Nimisha Chabba

Nimisha Chabba

PhD candidate

Claire O'Shea

Claire O'Shea

Podiatrist & PhD candidate

Deborah Ewuru

Deborah Ewuru

PhD candidate

Renata Watene

Renata Watene

Ngā Puhi | Tainui | PhD candidate

First up was Nimisha Chabba, who plans to develop better methods to measure access to diabetes eye care services. Her work is internationally relevant, and her findings may change the World Health Organization’s reporting guidelines for diabetic eye care.

For Nimisha, a PhD in the Community Eye Health team flows naturally from her previous experiences in public health with the Fred Hollows Foundation. Her attention to detail and hard-working attitude were evident as she described the detailed protocol she has developed to summarise access to diabetes services in all countries of the world.   

“I’m glad to move past my provisional year so that I can focus on the next challenges,” says Nimisha.

Newly confirmed PhD candidates Claire O’Shea and Deborah Ewuru are also working to improve diabetes healthcare services, albeit closer to home, as part of our population-based health survey that will begin imminently within 2025.

Claire is the Lead Podiatrist at Waikato District Health Board, and she brings a refreshing new perspective to our research team which has, until now, been predominantly focused on eye care. To date, Claire has focused on identifying evidence for service integration—where sensory care services for vision, hearing, foot health, or diabetes are offered alongside each other. 

Compared to her clinical work, Claire describes her doctoral studies as “a new kind of challenge”, and it’s one that she’s rising to meet.

“It’s great to work with other more senior researchers,” says Claire, “because you realise we’re all facing similar challenges.”

Claire looks forward to 2025, where she will survey optometrists, audiologists, and podiatrists to work out how we can provide integrated services that are more accessible for patients.  

Deborah’s PhD project runs alongside Claire’s, but with a focus on vision and eye care services. Deborah brings her experiences as an Optometrist in Nigeria, where she operates her own eye care clinic for people with limited access to eye care. Since moving to New Zealand over a year ago, she has focused on increasing her knowledge of epidemiology that underlies her work. In the coming months, she will play a key role in conducting vision assessments in the community within our population-based survey in four regions of New Zealand. 

“I learned a lot from preparing for my provisional year review,” says Deborah, “and I feel more ready for what comes next.”

Most recently, we congratulate Renata Watene on her PhD candidature. Renata is an Optometrist with a passion for promoting eye heath for Māori and Indigenous Peoples. On returning to University from her clinical work, she describes an incredible year of learning opportunities as she gets up to speed with her colleagues.

“Giving my confirmation talk gave me an immense sense of achievement to look back at what was completed during my first year,” says Renata, “and it gave me a clearer sense of direction for my work.”

With the first major milestone complete, we wish all our doctoral students well as they move into the next phases of their doctoral pathway.

How to look after your eyes

How to look after your eyes

Everyday activities such as reading and playing are much more fun if you can see well! For adults and kaumātua, good eyesight means you can work, drive a car, and look after your whānau. Here are some tips for looking after your eyesight.

Feel free to download our E-Y-E-S-I-G-H-T eye health poster to share with friends, whanau, or at schools.

Eye health poster - eye checks

Eye checks

Going to your school eye screening appointments or diabetes eye checks is a great way to keep your eyes healthy. Visiting an optometrist every two years is recommended.

Eye health poster - yippee

Yippee!

Spending time outdoors is great for your eyes. Don’t forget to wear your sunglasses!

Eye health poster - eat healthy

Eat healthy

Healthy food builds healthy eyes. Fruit and vegetables are great for your eyesight.

Eye health poster - smart habits

Smart habits

Smoking and vaping can damage your eyesight and it’s best to avoid these activities.

Eye health poster - issues

Issues

If you notice any changes to your eyesight, your optometrist or family doctor can offer you advice.

Eye health poster - glasses

Glasses

If you need them, wearing your glasses or contact lenses makes it much easier for you to learn at school.

Eye health poster - Hauora

Hauora

Your eyes are a picture of your health and wellbeing. Look after your body and mind.

Eye health poster - talk

Talk

Check in with your whānau to see how they are looking after their health and wellbeing. Does anyone need support to see better?

Q&A with Deepa Kumar : Master of Health Science

Q&A with Deepa Kumar : Master of Health Science

Deepa Kumar

Deepa Kumar

Master's graduate

Deepa is an Optometrist and Clinical Team Leader at Counties Manukau Ophthalmology District Health Board. In 2020, she returned to The University of Auckland to complete her Master’s in Health Science with A/Prof Jacqueline Ramke in the Community Eye Health Team.

Now a Master’s graduate, Deepa reflects on what’s involved in postgraduate study and how she has applied her research experience in public health to her clinical work.

Thesis: Non-attendance at diabetic retinopathy screening in South Auckland.

“One thing I would recommend is selecting a project topic that you’re passionate about—something that resonates with your professional interests and goals.”

Why did you decide to do a Masters?

I wanted to deepen my understanding of research and public health.  I saw it as a chance to develop research skills that could help improve patient outcomes, influence healthcare policy, and address gaps in service, especially in underserved areas like South Auckland.

Can you tell us about your Masters project topic?

My Master’s thesis focused on the non-attendance at Diabetes Eye Services in South Auckland and the impact of COVID-19. Specifically, I wanted to understand the factors that led to patients missing their scheduled eye exams for diabetic retinopathy screening and diabetic eye assessments within a tertiary ophthalmology setting over a two-year period including during the Covid 19 pandemic.

My research showed that age, ethnicity, and socioeconomic status were associated with non-attendance at diabetic retinopathy screening services, and that Covid restrictions during this time presented additional barriers for diabetic patients.

I chose this topic because diabetic retinopathy is a leading cause of blindness in people with diabetes, and South Auckland has a higher proportion of people from ethnic groups at greater risk of both diabetes and related eye complications. 

What were the highlights of doing your Masters?

One of the biggest highlights of doing my Master’s was the opportunity to conduct research that could potentially make a real difference in patient attendance and hence patient care and outcomes.

Another highlight was the satisfaction of analysing data and uncovering patterns that could inform practical interventions. The process of collecting data, interpreting it, and then seeing the findings contribute to a deeper understanding of the problem was intellectually fulfilling.

I also appreciated the chance to develop stronger research, writing, statistical analysis, and critical thinking skills.

How has the experience you gained during your Masters contributed to your work?

The experience I gained during my Master’s has greatly influenced my work. The research process honed my ability to critically assess healthcare problems and solutions, which has been of great help in my clinical role at Counties Manukau. I now feel more confident in understanding and evaluating the health disparities that exist within different patient populations. This has helped me better communicate with my patients, especially in communities with high rates of diabetes, where education about eye care and screening is crucial. Additionally, the data analysis skills I developed during my research has helped in a recent clinic audit.

What advice would you give other optometrists thinking about doing a Masters?

My advice would be to approach the decision with clear goals in mind. The Master’s journey can be intense, and it’s important to have a clear understanding of what you want to achieve.

Going back to study (while working) was challenging but achievable, and ultimately very rewarding. You have to balance work and study, so it helps if you’re organized and set realistic expectations for yourself. I found that planning ahead and dedicating specific times to study made a huge difference. However, it’s also important to have support from family, colleagues, and supervisors.

One thing I would recommend is selecting a project topic that you’re passionate about—something that resonates with your professional interests and goals. Having a personal connection to your research will make the process more enjoyable and meaningful. It requires dedication and the ability to balance your professional and personal commitments.

 

“One year in”: A chat with Renata Watene about her experiences in academia

“One year in”: A chat with Renata Watene about her experiences in academia

Renata Watene

Renata Watene

Ngā Puhi | Tainui | PhD candidate

Renata Watene (Ngā Puhi, Tainui) is an Optometrist and advocate of Māori eye healthcare in Aotearoa. In 2023 she began her PhD in the Community Eye Health team, where she is exploring existing Indigenous models of eye care. Here she reflects on the challenges she has faced after her first year of doctoral studies.

Mā te kimi ka kite, Mā te kite ka mōhio, Mā te mōhio ka mārama

Seek to discover, Discover to know, Know and become enlightened

Why did you decide to do a PhD?

I would say the PhD chose me. I have been working in the optics space for more than 20 years now, and I have seen in the impacts of a privately funded health care model that creates inequities for consumers of Optometry services. In my own clinics I witnessed vast difference in services and outcomes for Māori patients. There is a large knowledge gap around Māori eyecare and use of Kaupapa Māori in Optometry in particular. With some intervention from my tupuna (grandmother) this path felt like the next step in making a meaningful impact in Optometry.

What’s the most challenging part of your studies so far?

The biggest challenge has been returning to academia from a clinical position and multiple community and governance roles. I was fortunate enough to secure a Clinical Research Fellowship through Health Research Council which contributed significantly by reducing the financial deficit that clinicians usually face if they return to do postgraduate studies.

As an alternative pathway applicant, I have had an incredible year of learning opportunities as I get up to speed with my other research colleagues. I think the feeling of imposter syndrome is very real in this space and it was comforting to learn that even those with significant research background still experience the same concerns that I do around progress of projects and validity of their research.

Working in Indigenous research adds another layer of complexity. Ensuring that the research meets the academic rigour of the Western system while being relationally accountable to our research partners and communities is at times near impossible. Working with Indigenous communities means that all processes and should be culturally appropriate and respected and that there is space for ceremony and tikanga. It is critical that I be very intentional to centre Māori and whānau voice as well, as Maori worldviews are important if we are to develop intergenerational strategies that address inequities. The western concept and indigenous concepts of time have been at odds during this process. ‘Mā te wā’ or all in good time.

What’s the most rewarding part?

The most rewarding part has been the opportunity to meet and learn from experts in equity and Indigenous eye health research. There is an obvious appetite from the local and global community toward more equitable outcomes for Māori and Indigenous Peoples, and it has been rewarding to contribute to conversations that address this. It’s a reminder of why I started this journey in the first place.

What was it like officially completing the first year of your PhD?

Giving my confirmation talk and looking back at what was completed during my first year gave me an immense sense of achievement and a clearer sense of direction for my work. But preparing for my provisional year review was challenging! Reprioritising my time and stepping back from several roles has helped me refine my focus and objectives into achievable goals for the remainder of the PhD journey. Like many processes in a PhD, you learn a lot and know how you would do things differently next time.

What are you focusing on now as you head into your second year?

Building on the strong foundation of my first year, I look forward to the next phases of my research and elevating the voices of our Māori, whānau, students, and practitioners in eyecare. I’m focusing on connecting with Indigenous Eyecare experts (and hopefully finding some more along the way!) to help inform a new eye health system that may lead to changes in how eyecare is delivered.